We love One Tree Hill but, like any show, it has a few storylines we could have done without. Mouth and his problematic relationships seem to be a common denominator.
Julie: Mouth Does Alice in Season Five
This was just gross! Alice was repulsive. And why was she constantly described as hot? She was not hot at all. This storyline would have probably been better with a different actress as Alice. But not much better.
Meaghan: Mouth Does Alice in Season Five
For one thing, this storyline was absolutely pointless. Did anything ever really come out of it? Nope. For another thing, all these characters kept referring to how “hot” Alice was. Alice was not hot. It made the whole thing seem even more ludicrous.
Morgan: Mouth Flirts with Gigi in Season Six
Sometimes I think the show brings characters back just because they’re really fond of the actor playing them. I think this is what happened with the return of Gigi Silveri in season six. Early in his relationship with Millie, Mouth showed disregard for her feelings by going to see Rachel. He did it again by letting Gigi come on to him again and again even though he knew how much it bothered Millie. The whole story is just stupid. Millie deserved better than Mouth flirting with his nymphomaniac high school ex-girlfriend.